William Marbury was appointed a justice of the peace for Washington County, in the District of Columbia. President John Adams signed his commission and the seal of the United States was fixed to it, but it never reached him. Marbury asked the Supreme Court to order the Secretary of State, James Madison, to deliver it. The Court's answer in Marbury v. Madison (1803) is why courts can strike down laws that conflict with the Constitution.
Chief Justice John Marshall's opinion, decided February 24, 1803, turns on three questions. This post takes them in order.
Did Marbury have a right to the commission?
Yes, the Court said. It held that "when a commission has been signed by the President, the appointment is made; and that the commission is complete, when the seal of the United States has been affixed to it by the secretary of state." Marbury was appointed, and the law gave him the office for five years. He was entitled to the commission as the paper that proved it.
Was there a legal remedy?
Also yes. The Court held that a person with a legal right can go to the courts to protect it, and that a writ of mandamus, a court order commanding an official to do a duty the law requires, is the kind of remedy that fits. Whether this Court could issue it was a separate question.
Could the Supreme Court issue the order?
This is where the case turned. Congress had passed the Judiciary Act of 1789, which authorized the Supreme Court "to issue writs of mandamus, in cases warranted by the principles and usages of law, to any courts appointed, or persons holding office, under the authority of the United States." The Secretary of State is exactly such an officer. Marbury had gone straight to the Supreme Court under that law.
But Article III of the Constitution says the Supreme Court has original jurisdiction, meaning it hears a case first, only in cases affecting ambassadors, other public ministers and consuls, and cases in which a state is a party. "In all other cases," it says, the Court has appellate jurisdiction. Marbury's case was neither. Marshall concluded that Congress could not give the Court a power the Constitution withheld, and that this part of the act could not stand.
To get there, he first had to say why a court may decide such a thing at all. He began with the Constitution as a written, fixed law: "an act of the legislature, repugnant to the constitution, is void." The question was whether a court must still apply a void law. His answer is the line the case is known for: "It is emphatically the province and duty of the judicial department to say what the law is." When a law and the Constitution conflict in a case, the court has to choose between them. "The court must determine which of these conflicting rules governs the case. This is of the very essence of judicial duty." The Court concluded that "a law repugnant to the constitution is void; and that courts, as well as other departments, are bound by that instrument." The rule Marbury sought was discharged: he had the right and the remedy, but not in that court.
Why it still matters
The result looks odd. Marbury won on the law and lost his case. The Court declined a power Congress had offered it, and in doing so it claimed a larger one: the power to measure acts of Congress against the Constitution. Every later argument that a court may set aside a statute begins from this opinion.
When you hear that a court has "struck down" a law, the step being taken is Marshall's. The opinion is worth reading in full, and each case name here links to it.
Sources
- Marbury v. Madison (1803), 5 U.S. 137: Library of Congress, U.S. Reports
- Article III, Constitution Annotated
Updated November 2026.
This post was rewritten with AI (Claude) and reviewed by an editor before publication.
