In 1972 the Supreme Court held that the death penalty, as it was imposed in the cases before it, was cruel and unusual punishment. Four years later it upheld a new Georgia statute. Since then the question has been who may be executed, and for what. Five decisions, from 1972 to 2005, mark the main turns.
The death penalty as imposed
Furman v. Georgia (1972), decided June 29, 1972. The cases came from Georgia, where one petitioner was sentenced to death for murder and another for rape, and from Texas, where a third was sentenced to death for rape. The Court's short unsigned opinion held that "the imposition and carrying out of the death penalty in these cases constitute cruel and unusual punishment in violation of the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments." The judgments were reversed insofar as they left the death sentences undisturbed. The unsigned opinion gives no reasons, and the justices wrote separately. Its holding is limited to "these cases."
A new Georgia statute
Gregg v. Georgia (1976), decided July 2, 1976. Gregg was convicted of two counts of armed robbery and two counts of murder, after evidence that he had killed and robbed two men. Georgia's procedure was bifurcated: the jury decided guilt first, then, at a separate penalty stage, decided the sentence, and could not consider death unless it found at least one aggravating circumstance beyond a reasonable doubt. The jury found two and returned a sentence of death. The judgment of the Court was announced in an opinion by Justices Stewart, Powell and Stevens, who wrote that "the punishment of death does not invariably violate the Constitution." They drew on the principle that the Amendment "must draw its meaning from the evolving standards of decency that mark the progress of a maturing society." The Court affirmed the Georgia Supreme Court.
Not for rape of an adult
Coker v. Georgia (1977), decided June 29, 1977. Coker escaped from a Georgia prison and, in the course of an armed robbery and other offenses, raped an adult woman. He was convicted and sentenced to death on the rape charge. Justice White, in an opinion joined by three other justices, concluded that "the sentence of death for the crime of rape is grossly disproportionate and excessive punishment and is therefore forbidden by the Eighth Amendment as cruel and unusual punishment."
Intellectual disability
Atkins v. Virginia (2002), decided June 20, 2002. Atkins was convicted of capital murder and sentenced to death by a Virginia jury, and he argued that he could not be executed because he was mentally retarded, the term the Court used then. Justice Stevens, for the Court, held that "executions of mentally retarded criminals are 'cruel and unusual punishments' prohibited by the Eighth Amendment." A punishment is "excessive," the Court said, if it is not graduated and proportioned to the offense, and proportionality review is informed by evolving standards of decency.
Under 18
Roper v. Simmons (2005), decided March 1, 2005. At age 17, Simmons planned and committed a capital murder. Justice Kennedy, for the Court, held that the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments forbid imposing the death penalty on offenders who were under 18 when their crimes were committed. The Court said that Stanford v. Kentucky (1989), which had rejected that rule for offenders 16 and 17, "should be deemed no longer controlling on this issue."
What the five decisions show
Furman stopped the death penalty as it was then imposed. Gregg allowed it under a statute with a bifurcated trial and guided sentencing. After that, the Court drew lines around who could be sentenced to death: not for the rape of an adult in Coker, not people with intellectual disability in Atkins, and not offenders under 18 in Roper. All three rest on the "evolving standards of decency" language that Gregg quoted. This post stops at 2005, and later decisions are not covered here.
Sources
- Furman v. Georgia (1972), 408 U.S. 238: Library of Congress, U.S. Reports
- Gregg v. Georgia (1976), 428 U.S. 153: Library of Congress, U.S. Reports
- Coker v. Georgia (1977), 433 U.S. 584: Library of Congress, U.S. Reports
- Atkins v. Virginia (2002), 536 U.S. 304: Library of Congress, U.S. Reports
- Roper v. Simmons (2005), 543 U.S. 551: Library of Congress, U.S. Reports
Updated November 2026.
This post was rewritten with AI (Claude) and reviewed by an editor before publication.
