Healthcare

The Impact of Supreme Court Decisions on Healthcare in America

Who pays, who decides and who can sue: nine Supreme Court cases on American healthcare, from Roe to Medina.

Etalia.ai
Dec 29, 2023
4 min read
AI-Rewritten, AI-Model-claude-sonnet-5-5

In 2012 the Supreme Court told the federal government it could not threaten states with the loss of all their existing Medicaid money to make them expand the program. The Court counted the stakes: the threatened loss was more than ten percent of a state's overall budget. It called that "economic dragooning." The sentence says something about the whole subject. Almost every Supreme Court case about American healthcare is about who pays, who decides, and who is allowed to stop someone else from doing either.

The nine cases below show how the Court has answered those questions, from the right to an abortion to the right to sue over a Medicaid provider. I have kept them in the order of the problem they address rather than the year, because the same three questions keep coming back.

Who decides what a doctor may do

Roe v. Wade (1973) is where most of the modern debate begins. Justice Blackmun wrote for a 7-2 Court that struck down Texas's abortion statutes and set out a framework by trimester: before about the end of the first, the decision belongs to the woman and her physician. Nearly fifty years later, in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization (2022), Justice Alito wrote for five justices that the Constitution does not confer a right to abortion, that Roe and Casey were overruled, and that the authority to regulate abortion returns "to the people and their elected representatives." The case concerned Mississippi's ban after 15 weeks. Chief Justice Roberts agreed with the judgment but not the overruling, and Justices Breyer, Sotomayor and Kagan dissented. For a hospital or insurer, the practical result is that the rules now differ by state.

The Court has also had to decide who gets to define "legitimate medicine." In 2001 the Attorney General issued an interpretive rule saying that using controlled substances to assist suicide was not a legitimate medical practice. Oregon's Death with Dignity Act allowed it. In Gonzales v. Oregon (2006) Justice Kennedy wrote for a 6-3 Court that the Controlled Substances Act did not give the Attorney General that power. Justices Scalia, Thomas and Chief Justice Roberts dissented.

A more recent case asked a narrower version of the question. Doctors and medical groups challenged the FDA's regulation of mifepristone, although they do not prescribe or use the drug themselves. In Food and Drug Administration v. Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine (2024) Justice Kavanaugh wrote for a unanimous Court that those plaintiffs had not shown the injury that standing requires: they were unregulated parties challenging the FDA's regulation of others.

Who pays for coverage

The Affordable Care Act was built on subsidies and a mandate, and it reached the Court more than once. National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius (2012) upheld the individual mandate under Congress's taxing power. It held the Medicaid expansion unconstitutional as written, because the penalty for refusing it was the loss of existing funding. The remedy was narrow: the Secretary may not withdraw existing Medicaid funds from a state that declines the expansion, and the rest of the Act stands.

Three years later, King v. Burwell (2015) asked whether tax credits are available to people who buy insurance through a federal exchange. The IRS said yes. Chief Justice Roberts wrote for a 6-3 Court that the statute should be read that way: "Congress passed the Affordable Care Act to improve health insurance markets, not to destroy them." Justice Scalia dissented, joined by Justices Thomas and Alito. The Court warned that the other reading would produce the kind of "calamitous result" Congress plainly meant to avoid.

Who can be made to cover what

The Act required most employers' health plans to cover contraceptives without cost-sharing. The government had already offered an accommodation to religious nonprofits that objected. In Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores (2014) the owners of three closely held for-profit corporations said that covering certain contraceptives would violate their religion. Justice Alito wrote for a 5-4 Court that the mandate, as applied to them, violated the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. Justice Ginsburg dissented. The Court held that, as applied to closely held corporations like these, the contraceptive mandate violated the Act.

Who can own and who can sue

Myriad Genetics discovered the location and sequence of the BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes, mutations of which can dramatically raise the risk of breast and ovarian cancer, and patented them. In Association for Molecular Pathology v. Myriad Genetics, Inc. (2013) Justice Thomas wrote for a unanimous Court that a naturally occurring segment of DNA is a product of nature and cannot be patented. Synthetic cDNA, which has only the exons, can be.

The most recent case turns on who may go to court. South Carolina excluded Planned Parenthood South Atlantic from its Medicaid program, and a patient sued under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, claiming that the federal "any-qualified-provider" provision gave patients a right to choose it. In Medina v. Planned Parenthood South Atlantic (2025) Justice Gorsuch wrote for a 6-3 Court that individual beneficiaries cannot enforce that provision through § 1983. Whether to give them that remedy, the Court said, is a question for Congress. Justice Jackson dissented, joined by Justices Sotomayor and Kagan.

What the pattern shows

These cases do not add up to a health policy. The Court has no authority to write one. It does, again and again, decide which level of government is allowed to attach a price to a choice: the federal government to a state's Medicaid budget, an employer to a worker's coverage, a state to a clinic's participation. Where the Constitution or Congress left that open, the Court has had to pick, and the picks have not always lasted: Roe stood for nearly fifty years before it was overruled.

Sources

Updated October 2026.


This post was rewritten with AI (Claude) and reviewed by an editor before publication.

etalia.ai

Subscribe to our Newsletter and stay up to date!

Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news and work updates straight to your inbox.

Oops! There was an error sending the email, please try again.

Awesome! Now check your inbox and click the link to confirm your subscription.