POTUS

Who Can Be President: What the Supreme Court Has Decided About Eligibility

Presidential eligibility sounds settled. The Supreme Court has spent its time on the edges: who is a citizen at birth, and who can enforce the clause that disqualifies a candidate.

Etalia.ai
Dec 21, 2023
6 min read
AI-Rewritten, AI-Model-claude-sonnet-5-5

On March 4, 2024, the Supreme Court did something rare: it told a state it could not act. Colorado's highest court had ruled that Donald Trump was disqualified from the presidency under the Fourteenth Amendment and could not appear on its primary ballot. The nine justices, writing without a single name on the opinion, said Colorado had no such power. Then they went home and left the actual question, who the Constitution bars from the presidency and who decides, mostly where they found it.

That is the odd thing about this subject. The Constitution gives presidents one eligibility test that courts have had to explain, and the cases that explain it were mostly not about presidents. They were about who is a citizen at birth, and, in 2024, about who can enforce the one clause that disqualifies a candidate. This post goes through those decisions, what each one decided, and what none of them did.

What the Constitution asks of a president

Article II says that no person except a natural-born citizen, or a citizen of the United States when the Constitution was adopted, can be President. The Court quoted that clause in Minor v. Happersett and then said the obvious thing: the Constitution does not, in words, say who the natural-born citizens are, and the answer has to be found elsewhere. Everything below follows from that gap.

Citizens at birth: from Minor to Wong Kim Ark

The first case to touch the phrase was not about the presidency at all. In Minor v. Happersett (1875), Virginia Minor argued that citizenship carried the right to vote. The Court said it did not, and a state could limit voting to men. Chief Justice Waite wrote that at common law it was never doubted that children born in a country to parents who were its citizens were themselves citizens, "natives, or natural-born citizens." As for children born here to parents who were not citizens, he noted that there had been doubts, and said the Court did not need to solve them.

It solved them 23 years later. In United States v. Wong Kim Ark (1898), a man born in San Francisco in 1873 to Chinese parents was refused entry when he returned from a visit to China. His parents were subjects of the Emperor of China but lived and did business in the United States and held no diplomatic or official role. Justice Gray, writing for the Court, held that the Fourteenth Amendment made him a citizen at birth. The case is about citizenship, not the presidency, and it did not say who may be president. But it settled the first step: a child born here to parents who live here is a citizen from the first day.

Citizens at birth, abroad

A child born outside the country to an American parent is a different problem, because the Fourteenth Amendment's rule is about birth in the United States. Congress decides by statute who is a citizen, and the Court has mostly let it set conditions.

Perkins v. Elg (1939) went the other way. Marie Elg was born in Brooklyn in 1907 to Swedish parents who had emigrated; her father was naturalized here in 1906. In 1911 her mother took her to Sweden, where she grew up. In 1929, within eight months of turning 21, she obtained an American passport and came back. Chief Justice Hughes wrote for the Court that she had kept her citizenship, which was hers by birth.

Rogers v. Bellei (1971) shows the other side. Aldo Bellei was born in Italy in 1939 to an American mother and an Italian father, and lived in Italy until recently. A statute made him a citizen on the condition that he live in the United States for five continuous years between the ages of 14 and 28. An American consul in Rome told him he had lost his citizenship. In a 5-4 decision, Justice Blackmun wrote that the Fourteenth Amendment covers people born or naturalized here, and Congress may attach conditions to citizenship it grants by statute to people born abroad.

Tuan Anh Nguyen v. INS (2001) concerned a different rule in the same statute. Tuan Anh Nguyen was born in Vietnam in 1969 to a Vietnamese mother and an American father, Joseph Boulais. A child born abroad and out of wedlock to a citizen mother is a citizen at birth if she meets a residency requirement. If the citizen parent is the father, one of three steps must be taken before the child turns 18: legitimation, a declaration of paternity under oath, or a court order of paternity. Nguyen did not meet them, and he was ordered deported after a criminal conviction. The Court held that the difference is consistent with the equal protection guarantee in the Fifth Amendment. In Sessions v. Morales-Santana (2017), the Court held that a separate gender line in the same statute, on how long a citizen parent must have lived in the United States before the child's birth, was incompatible with equal protection, and it treated Nguyen's rule as a different one.

None of these was a suit about whether someone could be president. But each decides who counts as a citizen at birth, and Article II's "natural-born" requirement depends on the answers.

The clause that can disqualify

Section 3 of the Fourteenth Amendment, written after the Civil War, bars from "any office, civil or military" anyone who took an oath to support the Constitution and then "engaged in insurrection or rebellion" against it. Congress "may by a vote of two-thirds of each House, remove such disability." For most of 150 years it was a historical footnote. In 2023 six Colorado voters asked a state court to keep Donald Trump off the state's primary ballot, saying Section 3 barred him.

The trial court found that Trump had "engaged in insurrection" but held that the Presidency is not an office "under the United States" and denied the petition. The Colorado Supreme Court, by a vote of 4 to 3, reversed that part and ordered Trump off the ballot. In Trump v. Anderson (2024), the Supreme Court reversed, in a per curiam opinion, an unsigned opinion for the Court. States have power over the qualifications and elections of their own officers, it said, but not the power to enforce Section 3 against candidates for federal office, especially the Presidency. Instead, responsibility "for enforcing Section 3 against federal officeholders and candidates rests with Congress and not the States."

All nine justices agreed on that result. They did not agree on the reasoning. Five justices went further and said that Section 3 can be enforced against federal candidates only when Congress passes legislation under Section 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment. Justices Sotomayor, Kagan and Jackson concurred only in the judgment, writing that the majority had decided "momentous and difficult issues unnecessarily." Justice Barrett joined part of the opinion but wrote that the point that States cannot enforce Section 3 against presidential candidates was enough to resolve the case, and that she would decide no more.

What did the Court not decide? It did not decide whether anyone took part in an insurrection; the Colorado findings were not before it. It did not say what legislation Congress would have to pass. Those questions were open before March 2024.

What has changed since 2023

When this post first ran in December 2023, the Court had not yet heard Anderson, and the post did not mention Section 3 at all. Anderson answered who enforces Section 3 against a federal candidate. Cases decided after the June 2025 end of the October 2024 term are not on scotus.etalia.ai yet, so this post does not cover them.

Why it matters now

The Court has said what the states cannot do about the one clause that can disqualify a candidate. It left the enforcement to Congress, and it did not say what Congress would have to do. And on the older question, what "natural-born" means for a candidate born abroad to an American parent, the cases above decide who is a citizen at birth and leave the rest to Article II's single sentence. A reader who wants to know who can be president should know that on both counts the answer is still partly unwritten.

Sources

Each case below is on its scotus.etalia.ai page, which links to the opinion.

Updated October 2026.


This post was rewritten with AI (Claude) and reviewed by an editor before publication.

etalia.ai

Subscribe to our Newsletter and stay up to date!

Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news and work updates straight to your inbox.

Oops! There was an error sending the email, please try again.

Awesome! Now check your inbox and click the link to confirm your subscription.