SCOTUS

Troxel v. Granville: Grandparents, Parents and Who Gets the Last Word

In 2000, the Supreme Court sided 6-3 with a mother who wanted to limit her daughters' visits with their late father's parents. The case set how much weight a parent's choice gets, and left open how far grandparents can push back.

Etalia.ai
Nov 18, 2026
8 min read
AI-Rewritten, AI-Model-claude-opus-5-5
A smiling young girl stands outdoors between an older man and an older woman who lean in close to her.
Photo by cottonbro studio on Pexels

In 1995, a judge in Washington State had to decide how often two young sisters should see their father's parents. Their father had died two years earlier. The girls' mother was willing to let the grandparents visit once a month. The grandparents wanted much more. Before he ruled, the judge talked about his own childhood and how much the time with his grandparents had meant to him.

Most of us bring a version of that judge to the Thanksgiving table: a firm picture of what family should look like, built from our own holidays. The trouble starts when two people at the same table hold different pictures, and one of them asks a court to choose.

That is the question in Troxel v. Granville (2000). When a parent and a grandparent disagree about visits, can a state let a judge overrule the parent because the judge believes more time with the grandparents would be good for the children? On June 5, 2000, the Supreme Court said no, at least not the way Washington did it. By a 6-3 vote, it ruled for the mother. It also left some of the hardest questions open, and states have been working through them ever since.

Two sisters and one weekend a month

Tommie Granville and Brad Troxel never married. They had two daughters, Isabelle and Natalie, and separated in 1991. Brad moved in with his parents, Jenifer and Gary Troxel, and regularly brought the girls to their home on weekends. In May 1993, Brad died by suicide.

For a few months afterward, the grandparents kept seeing the girls regularly. Then, in October 1993, Granville told them she wanted to limit their time to one short visit a month. In December, the Troxels went to court. They asked for two weekends of overnight visits every month and two weeks each summer. Granville did not ask the court to cut them off. She proposed one day a month, with no overnight stay.

The trial court came down closer to the grandparents: one weekend a month, one week in the summer, and four hours on each grandparent's birthday. Granville appealed. While the case went on, she married, and her husband adopted the girls.

A law that let anyone ask, at any time

The Troxels sued under a Washington statute that was unusually open. It let "any person" petition for visitation "at any time," and it let a judge order visits whenever they might serve the child's best interest. "Best interest of the child" is the standard family courts use in custody disputes. It asks the judge to weigh everything and choose what seems best for the child. The statute did not require the person asking to be a grandparent, or to show that the child would be harmed without the visits. It did not tell the judge to give the parent's wishes any special weight.

The Washington Court of Appeals threw out the order, holding that nonparents could not bring this kind of petition unless a custody case was already under way. The Washington Supreme Court went further and held the statute unconstitutional. It reasoned that the Constitution lets a state override a parent's decisions about her children only to prevent harm or potential harm to the child, and that the statute swept in far too many people and situations. The Troxels asked the US Supreme Court to review that ruling.

What the Court decided

Six justices agreed the Washington order could not stand, but they did not agree on why, so there is no majority opinion. The lead opinion, by Justice Sandra Day O'Connor, was joined by Chief Justice William Rehnquist and Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Stephen Breyer. Lawyers call this a plurality opinion: the opinion with the most votes on the winning side, but without a majority behind its reasoning.

The plurality started from the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, which bars states from depriving anyone of "liberty" without due process of law. The Court has long read that word to protect some rights the Constitution doesn't list, an idea called substantive due process. One of the earliest is the right of parents to direct how their children are raised. Justice O'Connor traced it through Meyer v. Nebraska (1923), which struck down a ban on teaching young children foreign languages, and Pierce v. Society of Sisters (1925), which struck down a law requiring children to attend public schools, and on through Prince v. Massachusetts (1944), Wisconsin v. Yoder (1972) and Santosky v. Kramer (1982). She described it as perhaps the oldest of the fundamental liberty interests the Court had recognized.

Against that background, the plurality called Washington's statute "breathtakingly broad." Under it, any judge who disagreed with a parent about visits could put his own view in place of hers. But the plurality did not strike the law down in every case. It held that the statute was unconstitutional as applied to Granville, for three connected reasons:

  • No one had alleged, and the court had not found, that Granville was an unfit parent. The law presumes that fit parents act in their children's best interests.
  • The trial judge gave Granville's decision no special weight. If anything, he started from a presumption in favor of grandparent visits and put the burden on her to show they would be bad for the girls.
  • Granville had never tried to cut the grandparents off. She had offered regular visits. The fight was over how many.

Just as important is what the plurality declined to decide. It did not say whether a state must show harm to the child before ordering visits over a parent's objection, which is what the Washington Supreme Court had required. It did not say that every third-party visitation law is unconstitutional. It said those questions depend on how such laws are written and applied, and left them for another day.

The power of a starting point

We usually tell this case as a contest between two kinds of love: grieving grandparents on one side, a mother protecting her new family on the other. But look at it another way. Troxel is really a case about defaults.

Behavioral scientists have shown how much a default can decide. In a widely cited 2003 paper in Science, Eric Johnson and Daniel Goldstein compared European countries where people had to opt in to be organ donors with countries where people were donors unless they opted out. Consent rates were far higher in the opt-out countries, even though the underlying choice was the same. Later researchers have argued that the effect on actual transplants is smaller than the consent figures suggest. A 2019 study in Kidney International comparing 35 countries found no significant difference in deceased organ donors between opt-out and opt-in systems. So defaults don't decide everything. What they do decide is the close calls, and who has to do the persuading.

That is what Troxel changed. The Washington trial court began from the assumption that more grandparent time was good and asked the mother to prove otherwise. The plurality reversed the starting point. A fit parent's decision comes first, and a judge who wants to override it needs more than his own sense of what a good childhood looks like, however fondly he remembers his own. Grandparents can still win. They just begin behind.

Five more opinions and no clean answer

Justice David Souter agreed with the result but would simply have affirmed the Washington Supreme Court's ruling that the statute was invalid on its face, meaning in every application. Justice Clarence Thomas also agreed with the result. He noted that neither side had asked the Court to reconsider substantive due process, and said that because the parental right is fundamental, he would judge the law under strict scrutiny, the most demanding test the Court uses.

Three justices dissented, each for different reasons. Justice John Paul Stevens stressed that children have interests of their own, including in relationships with people who love them, and argued that the Washington court was wrong to strike the statute down in all its applications. Justice Antonin Scalia wrote that the right of parents to raise their children is among the rights the people retain, but that the Constitution doesn't give judges the power to enforce it against state laws; he would have left the matter to legislatures. Justice Anthony Kennedy would have sent the case back. He disagreed that a showing of harm is always required, pointing to situations where someone other than a parent has acted as a parent in a child's life.

The result is a case with a clear outcome and a blurry rule. Parents won, and the right was reaffirmed. But no single opinion spoke for five justices on how much deference parents get, or when the state may step in.

What's changed since 2000

Every state had some form of grandparent visitation law when Troxel was decided, and the ruling sent legislatures and state courts back to work. Many states rewrote their laws to require courts to give special weight to a fit parent's decision, and some added a requirement to show harm to the child. State supreme courts have split on whether harm is constitutionally required, the question the plurality left open. Connecticut's, in Roth v. Weston (2002), read its statute to require proof of a parent-like relationship and real and significant harm to the child without visits, while Ohio's, in Harrold v. Collier (2005), upheld that state's law because it lets judges give special weight to a parent's wishes. The US Supreme Court has not returned to grandparent visitation directly.

The foundation of the case has drawn new attention. In Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization (2022), the Court overruled Roe v. Wade (1973) and Planned Parenthood of Southeastern Pennsylvania v. Casey (1992), applying the history-focused test for unlisted rights from Washington v. Glucksberg (1997). The majority said its ruling should not be read to cast doubt on precedents that do not concern abortion. Justice Thomas, writing only for himself, urged the Court to reconsider its substantive due process cases generally. The parental right in Troxel rests on that same doctrine, though it is among the oldest and most widely accepted rights the doctrine protects.

Parents' rights claims have also found another route. In Mahmoud v. Taylor (2025), decided 6-3 in June 2025, the Court held that parents in Montgomery County, Maryland, were likely to succeed on their claim that the Free Exercise Clause entitled them to notice and the chance to opt their children out of lessons using LGBTQ-themed storybooks. The majority leaned heavily on Yoder. Disputes over school policies on students' gender identity, and whether parents must be told, have reached the Court as well. In March 2026, in an emergency order in Mirabelli v. Bonta, the Court said parents challenging California's policies were likely to succeed on their free exercise and due process claims. In April it declined to hear a similar Massachusetts case, Foote v. Ludlow School Committee. It has also agreed to hear International Partners for Ethical Care v. Ferguson, about whether parents have standing to challenge a Washington law on notifying parents about minors seeking gender-affirming care, with argument set for December 7, 2026.

Why it matters at the holiday table

This month, plenty of families will set a table with someone missing: a grandparent who wasn't invited, a son who died, an in-law no one calls anymore. Troxel doesn't tell any of them who should be there. It says who decides when the adults can't agree. A fit parent's answer is not the only one that counts, but it comes first, and the state needs a real reason to replace it. The Court didn't hold that grandparents matter less. It held that a family's own imperfect choices deserve more respect than a well-meaning judge's memory of how things worked in his.

Sources

etalia.ai

Subscribe to our Newsletter and stay up to date!

Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news and work updates straight to your inbox.

Oops! There was an error sending the email, please try again.

Awesome! Now check your inbox and click the link to confirm your subscription.