SCOTUS

The Second Amendment in Five Supreme Court Cases

Cruikshank, Heller, McDonald, Bruen and Rahimi: how the Court went from a limit on Congress to a history test for gun laws.

Etalia.ai
Oct 29, 2025
4 min read
Second Amendment, Amendment Series, AI-Rewritten, AI-Model-claude-opus-5-5

The Second Amendment is one sentence: "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed." For most of American history the Supreme Court said very little about what it means. Five decisions, from 1876 to 2024, show how that changed, and where the Court has drawn the limits.

Only a limit on Congress

United States v. Cruikshank (1876), decided March 27, 1876. The federal government indicted men on counts that included conspiring to prevent citizens from "bearing arms for a lawful purpose." Chief Justice Waite wrote that this "is not a right granted by the Constitution. Neither is it in any manner dependent upon that instrument for its existence." The Second Amendment, he said, "means no more than that it shall not be infringed by Congress." It was one of the amendments that restricted "the powers of the national government," leaving people to look to the states for protection against private violations. On that reading the Amendment did not reach private violations or state laws, and the Court held the counts defective.

An individual right

District of Columbia v. Heller (2008), decided June 26, 2008. Dick Heller, a D.C. special police officer, applied to register a handgun he wished to keep at home. The District refused. Its law made it a crime to carry an unregistered firearm and prohibited registering handguns, and it required residents to keep lawfully owned firearms unloaded and either disassembled or bound by a trigger lock.

Justice Scalia wrote for the Court that the Second Amendment "protects an individual right to possess a firearm unconnected with service in a militia, and to use that arm for traditionally lawful purposes, such as self-defense within the home." The ban on handguns was an unconstitutional prohibition on "an entire class of 'arms' that Americans overwhelmingly choose for the lawful purpose of self-defense," and the trigger-lock requirement, as applied to self-defense, made it impossible to use a firearm for its core purpose. The Court also warned that the right is "not unlimited." Its opinion should not be taken to "cast doubt on longstanding prohibitions on the possession of firearms by felons and the mentally ill, or laws forbidding the carrying of firearms in sensitive places such as schools and government buildings, or laws imposing conditions and qualifications on the commercial sale of arms."

The states are bound too

McDonald v. City of Chicago (2010), decided June 28, 2010. Heller involved the District of Columbia, a federal enclave. Chicago and the suburb of Oak Park had handgun bans of their own, and the question was whether the right applied to the states. Justice Alito, for the Court on this point, held that the Fourteenth Amendment incorporates the Second Amendment right recognized in Heller: the right to keep and bear arms for self-defense applies to state and local governments through the Due Process Clause.

A new test: history

New York State Rifle & Pistol Association, Inc. v. Bruen (2022), decided June 23, 2022. New York required anyone who wanted an unrestricted license to carry a handgun in public to show "proper cause," a special need for self-protection "distinguishable from that of the general community." Brandon Koch and Robert Nash, law-abiding residents with only a general interest in self-defense, were denied. Justice Thomas, for the Court, held that the requirement prevents law-abiding citizens with ordinary self-defense needs from exercising their right to bear arms in public.

The decision also changed the test courts apply. Lower courts had used a two-step framework that combined history with "means-end" balancing. The Court rejected the second step. When the Amendment's plain text covers someone's conduct, the Constitution presumptively protects it, and to justify a regulation "the government must demonstrate that the regulation is consistent with the Nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation."

Applying that test

United States v. Rahimi (2024), decided June 21, 2024. Zackey Rahimi was indicted under a federal law, 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(8), that bars people subject to certain domestic violence restraining orders from possessing firearms. After Bruen, the Fifth Circuit held the law unconstitutional because the government had not shown it fit within the Nation's tradition of firearm regulation. Chief Justice Roberts, for the Court, reversed: "When an individual has been found by a court to pose a credible threat to the physical safety of another, that individual may be temporarily disarmed consistent with the Second Amendment." Since the founding, the Court found, firearm laws have included regulations to stop people who threaten others from misusing guns. The Court said the Second Amendment permits more than regulations identical to those that existed in 1791.

Where this leaves the law

The Court has now said three things. The right belongs to individuals and covers self-defense, at home and in public. It applies against states and cities. And a gun law is tested against history, not balanced against its benefits. Rahimi shows that the history test has room for modern laws that match older principles. How closely a modern law must resemble an old one is the question the test leaves open.

Sources

Updated November 2026.


This post was rewritten with AI (Claude) and reviewed by an editor before publication.

etalia.ai

Subscribe to our Newsletter and stay up to date!

Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news and work updates straight to your inbox.

Oops! There was an error sending the email, please try again.

Awesome! Now check your inbox and click the link to confirm your subscription.